Brian Matthews


Song Pick: “Don’t you want me” by The Human League

I sometimes hear from DOC staff that I’m just a whiney-poo prisoner whom over-criticizes
DOC for no reason. For any skeptics that might take issue with my criticism of DOC and
other State agencies’ lack of integrity when it comes to accessing public records,
perhaps you should become acquainted with ‘State Integrity Investigation,’ conducted by
The Center for Public Integrity (CPI).
The State Integrity Investigation is reported as a comprehensive assessment of state
government accountability and transparency. In 2015, Washington State received an “F”
grade in the category “Public Access to Information” and ranked 32nd nationally for that
category. According to the report, Katherine George, a Seattle Attorney and then-member
of the Washington Coalition for Open Government, was not surprised by the State’s dismal
grade for public disclosure. As she put it, there was a general misperception by state
agencies that unreasonable delays in complying with active records requests are
permissible if based on staffing constraints. I can personally attest that DOC usually
takes 100+ days to process a general public records request; when I challenged their
antics in court, DOC claimed staffing constraints in the attempt to justify the callous
disregard of their statutory duty to “promptly” make records available upon request.

George is quoted: “Often, agencies could eliminate backlogs if they devoted as much
staffing to records disclosures as they do to the public relations[.]” Getting the
public records you seek would be faster and easier if state agencies “worried less about
over-disclosing, which is protected from liability, and worried more about
under-disclosing.” Again, in line with George’s statement, I can personally attest that
DOC consistently over-redacts and over-withholds records which, after being challenged
at a court hearing, end up being disclosed.

George is concerned that Washington is failing to live up to its commitment to ensuring
citizens’ access to government records and data. The Washington State Public Records Act
(PRA) was originally enacted by voter Initiative in 1972, and when it became a law there
were less than a dozen exemptions for disclosures–meaning there were less than 12
reasons why a government agency could refuse to give a requester public records. Today,
there are more than 400 exemptions, and that number seems to jump dramatically every
year, meaning our government becomes more and more secret in its day-to-day operations.

I do my best to enforce the PRA whenever an agency refuses to comply with its
provisions, but I’m at a tremendous disadvantage of being incarcerated and without
adequate means to properly prosecute my cases. Very few of our State agencies seem to
care about meeting the obligations imposed under the PRA, and it’s to the detriment of
the citizens of our State to be kept ignorant of what our public servants are doing in
their posts. The PRA is a very valuable resource, and it is something that I believe
more People should utilize and enforce. From our legislative chambers to local counties
and cities, the PRA is consistently being violated. When we rank 32nd nationally for
public access to records, perhaps I’m not just a bored prisoner criticizing governmental
ineptitude because I have nothing better to do. Perhaps there actually is merit to what
I write about, and since it is the People’s tax dollars which funds such inept service,
perhaps the People should take notice that they’re getting exactly what they pay
for–whether they realize it or not. The CPI report can be viewed at:


DOC #796769


Categories: Brian Matthews

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s